Fitness Claims
Request a claimCaffeine supplementation improves exercise performance
100% Strongly SupportedCaffeine is the world's most widely consumed psychoactive substance and one of the most researched ergogenic aids in sports science. The cla...
Cold showers and cold water immersion improve exercise recovery
100% Insufficient EvidenceThe claim is that cold water immersion (CWI) or cold showers after exercise reduce muscle soreness (DOMS), decrease inflammation, and speed ...
Creatine monohydrate improves strength and power output
100% Strongly SupportedCreatine monohydrate is one of the most extensively studied sports supplements. The claim is that regular creatine supplementation (typicall...
Foam rolling reduces delayed-onset muscle soreness
100% Strongly SupportedFoam rolling (self-myofascial release) is a fixture of gym recovery routines. This claim is narrow on purpose: does rolling after exercise *...
Grip strength predicts how long you will live
100% Strongly SupportedLarge prospective cohorts and meta-analyses covering millions of people consistently find that weaker handgrip strength predicts earlier dea...
Higher protein intake increases muscle growth
100% Strongly SupportedThe claim is that consuming higher amounts of dietary protein (typically 1.6-2.2 g/kg/day) leads to greater increases in muscle mass during ...
Sleep quality significantly affects muscle growth
100% Insufficient EvidenceThe claim is that adequate sleep quality and duration (typically 7-9 hours per night) plays a critical role in muscle growth and recovery fr...
Cold water immersion after resistance training blunts muscle growth
79.1% SupportedPost-exercise cold water immersion reliably reduces soreness, but the question here is narrower: does using it habitually after lifting *int...
Electrolyte drinks hydrate better than plain water
74.8% SupportedElectrolyte drinks (sports drinks, oral rehydration solutions, and powdered mixes such as LMNT or Liquid I.V.) are marketed on the premise t...
Tart cherry juice improves sleep
73.7% SupportedMontmorency tart cherries contain melatonin and tryptophan, and several small human trials report modest sleep gains: **+34 minutes of sleep...
High-dose vitamin D supplementation causes harm in healthy adults
73.3% SupportedVitamin D is fat-soluble and stored in the body, and megadose products (5,000-50,000 IU) are sold freely. The claim is that taking high dose...
Red light therapy improves muscle recovery and exercise performance
66.1% SupportedManufacturers of red-light panels, masks and laser devices — and a research literature on photobiomodulation therapy (PBMT) / low-level lase...
Large calorie deficits cause more muscle loss than moderate ones
58.4% Mixed EvidenceThe standard advice against "crash dieting" holds that the size of an energy deficit determines how much of the resulting weight loss comes ...
Full range of motion is better than partial reps for hypertrophy
52.9% Insufficient EvidenceA common training recommendation is that exercises should be performed through a full range of motion rather than partial repetitions to max...
Interval walking training beats continuous walking for fitness and health
51.2% Mixed EvidenceThe viral "Japanese walking" method — alternating 3 minutes fast with 3 minutes slow — is unusual among fitness trends in having a real tria...
Static stretching before training reduces strength and power output
41.6% Mixed EvidenceCoaches, textbooks and popular training advice widely hold that holding a static stretch before a workout or competition acutely impairs sub...
Creatine is especially beneficial for women over 40 and postmenopausal women
41.1% Mixed EvidenceMarketing and much of the popular coverage of creatine now positions midlife and postmenopausal women as the group with the most to gain, ci...
Training each muscle 3+ times per week is better than once
38% Weakly SupportedThe claim is that training each muscle group with a higher frequency (3 or more times per week) produces greater hypertrophy than a traditio...
Caffeine blunts creatine's ergogenic effect
35.9% Weakly SupportedA 1996 study found that men who took caffeine alongside a creatine loading phase lost creatine's performance benefit entirely, and the findi...
Stretching makes muscles permanently longer
31.4% Weakly SupportedA common explanation for why regular stretching improves flexibility is mechanical: the muscle is said to be physically lengthened — fascicl...
Intermittent fasting burns more fat than regular eating patterns
29.1% Weakly SupportedIntermittent fasting (IF) protocols such as 16:8 or alternate-day fasting have surged in popularity as fat loss strategies. The claim is tha...
Turkesterone increases testosterone and builds muscle
26.9% Weakly SupportedTurkesterone is an ecdysteroid from *Ajuga turkestanica*, sold as a "natural anabolic" on the claim that it builds muscle comparably to anab...
Weight-loss plateaus are caused by metabolic adaptation rather than under-reported food intake
25.8% Weakly SupportedA common explanation for stalled fat loss is that the body has entered "starvation mode": metabolism has slowed enough to cancel out the cal...
Berberine causes meaningful weight loss
23.2% Weakly SupportedBerberine is marketed as "nature's Ozempic", which implies a weight-loss effect in the same class as a GLP-1 agonist. The meta-analytic evid...
Vitamin D supplementation improves muscle strength and athletic performance
21.4% Weakly SupportedVitamin D is widely marketed to lifters and athletes as a performance supplement, on the basis that vitamin D receptors are present in skele...
The anabolic window requires protein within 30 minutes post-workout
20.5% Weakly SupportedThe "anabolic window" theory claims that consuming protein within a narrow window (typically 30-60 minutes) after resistance exercise is cri...
BPC-157 accelerates tendon and muscle healing in humans
19.2% Not SupportedBPC-157 ("Body Protection Compound 157") is a synthetic pentadecapeptide sold by peptide vendors and prescribed by some wellness clinics as ...
Continuous glucose monitors improve health outcomes in people without diabetes
19% Not SupportedOver-the-counter continuous glucose monitors (Stelo, Lingo, Levels) are marketed to people without diabetes on the premise that seeing your ...
Creatine makes women gain water weight and look bloated
19% Not SupportedA widely repeated reason women avoid creatine is that it causes noticeable water retention — several pounds of "water weight" and a puffy, b...
Seed oils are harmful to health
17.8% Not Supported"Seed oils" — soybean, sunflower, corn, canola, safflower — are the main dietary source of linoleic acid, an omega-6 fat. The claim, as popu...
Creatine supplementation impairs kidney function in healthy adults
3.8% Not SupportedOne of the most persistent worries about creatine is that it damages the kidneys. The claim is that regular supplementation (typically 3-5 g...
BCAA supplements are worth taking for muscle growth
0% Insufficient EvidenceBranched-chain amino acids (BCAAs — leucine, isoleucine, and valine) are widely marketed as supplements that promote muscle protein synthesi...
Certain foods spike cortisol and cause 'cortisol belly' and facial puffiness
0% Insufficient EvidenceSocial media claims that specific foods ("cortisol-triggering foods") chronically elevate cortisol, producing a "cortisol belly" and a puffy...
Creatine degrades into creatinine when mixed into hot drinks
0% Insufficient EvidenceThe advice not to stir creatine into coffee or tea rests on a real piece of chemistry: creatine in water slowly cyclizes into creatinine, an...
Most people need to supplement electrolytes daily
0% Not SupportedElectrolyte powders and drink mixes are marketed for daily use by the general population, on the premise that ordinary diets and plain water...
Foam rolling speeds recovery of muscle function and subsequent performance
0% Insufficient EvidenceThe second half of the foam-rolling promise: that rolling after training doesn't just make you *feel* better, but actually restores strength...
Lateral raises are the best exercise for lateral deltoids
0% Insufficient EvidenceA common recommendation in bodybuilding is that dumbbell lateral raises are the superior exercise for targeting the lateral (middle) head of...
You can target fat loss in specific body areas
0% Insufficient EvidenceA persistent fitness myth is that performing exercises targeting a specific body part (e.g., crunches for belly fat) will reduce fat in that...
Static stretching before exercise prevents injuries
0% Not SupportedA widespread belief in fitness that performing static stretching before exercise reduces the risk of musculoskeletal injuries during the act...
Training to muscular failure maximizes muscle hypertrophy
0% Not SupportedThe claim that taking every set to complete muscular failure (inability to complete another rep) is necessary or optimal for maximizing musc...